Friday, 20 November 2026

Subscribe Now

Builder cannot sell open or stilt parking in Ulwe society, appellate court rules

Civic PT24 City Desk

The Maharashtra State Cooperative Appellate Court has directed a housing society in Ulwe to frame rules for parking allotment. The court said clearly that a builder can neither sell nor allot open or stilt parking space, whether to other parties or to flat holders. The rules must be framed in line with the society's approved bye-laws, and members must get parking accordingly.

The case concerns Greenview Cooperative Housing Society in Ulwe. Three of its members had filed an appeal against irregularities in parking allotment. The Raigad Cooperative Court had dismissed their complaint. The appellate court allowed the appeal and set aside the lower court's orders.

The court said the society has so far framed no rules for parking allotment, and the builder has no right to sell or allot parking. The society must therefore first frame rules in line with the approved bye-laws and then allot parking accordingly.

The society has 42 properties, of which 37 are residential flats and five are commercial units. The building's approved construction plan permitted only 18 parking spaces, while 29 parking slots were actually planned in the area.

The builder had given some flat holders mutual parking spaces, and some members had claimed to have bought parking from the builder. The appellant members argued that the builder had no right to sell or allot parking in this way. They also said that rules for parking allotment had to be made with the approval of the general meeting, but the society ignored this.

These members had complained in November 2018 to the Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies at CIDCO, Navi Mumbai. In January 2019, the Joint Registrar asked the society to take appropriate action. The members allege that the society took no concrete step on this.

In its reply before the cooperative court, the society had accepted that, under the approved bye-laws, parking rules had to be made with the approval of the general meeting. It claimed, however, that the builder's parking allotments had been discussed and approved at the first general meeting on November 18, 2018.

When the appellate court examined the agenda and minutes of the meeting, it found that parking was not on the agenda at all and no resolution on allotment was recorded. The society had also accepted in its written reply that the minutes contain no such mention.

The court said open and stilt parking areas are part of the building's common area and the builder cannot sell them separately. It said the dispute over the failure to frame parking rules is a matter of internal management between the society and its members, so the cooperative court has the authority to hear it under Section 91 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960.

The court also said that if parking spaces are fewer than the number of members, allotment must be fair and transparent. No member can be left out of consideration for parking on the ground that they do not live there themselves or have rented out their flat.

The court held wrong the lower court's conclusion that the appellants had not established any valid claim to parking. It directed the society to frame parking rules in line with the approved rules and to enforce them through the managing committee.

#Mumbai#Civic#PT24#शहर#मुंबई

Choose primetime24.com as a preferred source on Google Google shows more stories from your preferred sources in Top Stories.

Advertisement