128 trees to go for CSMT redevelopment: 56 to be felled, 72 to be replanted
Images are not validated/verified
Mumbai's tree authority has cleared the removal of 128 trees for the Rs 2,400 crore redevelopment of CSMT, even as questions over their age and survival rates persist.
The Mumbai Tree Authority has approved the removal of 128 trees for the Rs 2,400 crore redevelopment of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Terminus (CSMT) station. The proposal was put forward by the railways' redevelopment agency and passed by the authority.
Of the 128 trees, 56 will be felled permanently, while the remaining 72 will be replanted elsewhere. The decision has revived the debate over protecting old trees and Mumbai's green cover.
In return, a total of 2,463 trees are planned at designated sites in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region, outside municipal limits. Of these, 1,204 trees will be planted on railway land at Thakurli East in Thane. Another 1,259 trees are proposed in the embankment area of Digha.
Objections have been raised over the age of the trees. Opposition members say some of the affected trees may be more than 50 years old and could qualify as heritage trees. The municipal corporation's garden department has put the age of the trees at about 40 to 50 years. Even so, concern was expressed that the trees' ages may have been understated to obtain approval for the redevelopment.
Questions have also been asked about the condition of trees removed in the previous phase. According to official records, permission was given in 2024 to fell 86 trees and replant 180 in the same area. Environmentalists claim some of the affected trees may have been more than 60 years old. Doubts have also been raised over how many of the replanted trees actually survive.
Supporters of the redevelopment, on the other hand, say it is necessary to provide passengers with state-of-the-art facilities. One option put forward is that some of the affected trees could be replanted in a municipal garden adjoining the station. The railway administration has said the plantation work will be carried out as per the rules.
CSMT station is on UNESCO's list of World Heritage Sites. The redevelopment aims to turn it into a modern transport hub on the lines of an airport. While retaining the station's historic Victorian Gothic architecture, the emphasis will be on state-of-the-art passenger facilities. Attention will also be given to coordination between different modes of transport, reducing crowding and developing public spaces.
The administration has said the age of the affected trees was assessed by garden experts and technical officers of the municipal corporation's garden department.
Some questions remain, including whether old trees should be given heritage status, the survival rate of trees after replanting, and the actual results of compensatory plantation. The focus now is on how the environment and historic trees will be protected while Mumbai's infrastructure is developed.
Reach readers on the ward they actually live in.
Advertise with Prime Time 24Reach readers on the ward they actually live in.
Advertise with Prime Time 24Reach readers on the ward they actually live in.
Advertise with Prime Time 24Choose primetime24.com as a preferred source on Google Google shows more stories from your preferred sources in Top Stories.
Reach readers on the ward they actually live in.
Advertise with Prime Time 24
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.